Late double knocks Exeter City out of Carabao Cup

Ethan Sutherland had a night he'll want to forgetplaceholder image
Ethan Sutherland had a night he'll want to forget | Exeter City FC

The Grecians suffered stoppage-time heartbreak as Plymouth Argyle struck twice after debutant Ethan Sutherland was sent off

Two stoppage-time goals and a red card brought a painful end to the Grecians’ season-opener at Home Park.

Exeter City suffered late Devon derby heartbreak as Plymouth Argyle scored twice in stoppage time to knock them out of the Carabao Cup.

Former Grecian Alex Hartridge broke the deadlock in the 91st minute before Bim Pepple added a second moments later to give Argyle a 2-0 victory.

City also finished with ten players after debutant Ethan Sutherland (pictured) whose loan move from Wolverhampton Wanderers had been announced hours earlier, received two yellow cards during his 25-minute appearance.

Matt Taylor made one change from the side which started Exeter’s final pre-season fixture against Bristol City. Jake Doyle-Hayes returned to the starting line-up for the first time since February, while former Grecian Harry Kite joined Sutherland on the bench.

Plymouth included Hartridge, who came through Exeter’s academy, in their starting side.

The hosts created the better early openings. Harvey White fired wide before Hartridge’s cross found Pepple at the back post, but the striker scuffed his effort behind.

Ronan Curtis then forced a routine save from City goalkeeper Jack Bycroft after meeting a ball across the penalty area.

Exeter’s first meaningful opportunity came after 28 minutes. Reece Cole delivered a free-kick into the Argyle box and Charlie Cummins collected it at the far post, but his curling effort drifted narrowly wide.

Bycroft was called into action again before half-time, producing a full-stretch save to deny Pepple.

City began the second half brightly, with Taylor Perry firing over from the edge of the box before Andrew Oluwabori headed another Cole delivery above the crossbar.

Pepple missed a golden opportunity to put Plymouth ahead when he headed over from point-blank range.

Former City midfielder Kite then misplaced a pass towards Bycroft, but Will Evans failed to capitalise and fired high and wide from six yards.

The match appeared to be heading towards penalties until Sutherland was dismissed with three minutes of normal time remaining.

Argyle made the extra man count in stoppage time. Hartridge rose at the far post to score against his former club before Freddie Issaka won the ball and set up Pepple to add a rapid second.

Exeter will now turn their attention to their opening League One fixture in Lincolnshire next weekend.

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice