Peter Moore: 'Torbay Hospital must not be downgraded'


Torbay Weekly's retired GP columnist gives his verdict on future health service fears
Despite its problems the NHS is fantastic in an emergency. Torbay Hospital is at the heart of South Devon. It also has the advantage of being at the end of two dual carriageways. With our older population it offers a vital lifesaving service to our community.
But is the service at risk? The Devon Integrated Care Board (ICB) have the role of looking at health care across Devon. Their job is to put together plans for the future of our NHS following public consultation. The problem is that they are as open as GCHQ. They pulled out of the last public meeting, sighting the local elections even though there are no local elections in South Devon. The excuse sounded as convincing as “the dog ate my homework.” With the latest news that the hospital is offering a voluntary redundancy scheme. Is there a move to shrink Torbay Hospital and make it a satellite of Exeter?
Last year there was a proposal to move the out of hours cardiac catheterisation service to Exeter as a trial. Sadly, heart attacks do not stop for nights and weekends. If anyone has a heart attack the cardiac team can quickly put in a plastic tube called a stent to open up the artery. The quicker this can be done the less damage there will be to the heart muscle. The Torbay Unit is one of the best in the country. After protests this idea was paused, not cancelled.
It is difficult to separate rumours from fact but they all point in the same direction, shirking the services offered at Torbay and making Exeter the major hospital. It seems sensible for Torbay and Royal Devon and Exeter Hospitals to collaborate as equals, especially for elective work where there is not an emergency. The catchment area of Torbay Hospital has a larger and older population than Exeter, especially if we include holidaymakers. Unfortunately, it looks as though the ICB do not see the two hospitals as equal partners. Some departments at Torbay appear to be winding down. Some vacant jobs are not being filled.
Hospital departments do not work in isolation. Any change in one department will have a knock-on effect elsewhere. If we lost the emergency heart unit it would be difficult to justify an intensive care unit (ICU) where cardiac backup is essential. If we did not have an ICU the hospital could only carry out the most basic surgery. It would not be safe to operate on any patient with another medical problem when there is no ICU.
There is a proposal to move some of the pathology labs. If surgeons are operating on a suspected cancer they often remove the tumour, send it to the lab and wait for the result before deciding the scope of the operation. This would be impossible if the sample was sent away. Possible cancer surgery would have to be performed in Exeter.
There is also a suggestion that the Accident and Emergency Department could be downgraded to only open during the day. With a larger and older population than Exeter and a large number of holiday makers this idea makes no sense, Where would the ambulance take someone at four in the afternoon if the A & E department is about to close for the night? With no ICU or heart unit major trauma would be taken to Exeter leaving Torbay as little more than a minor treatment centre.
The ambulance service has not been consulted. Are there enough ambulances to cope with all the transfers from the whole of South Devon? Will ambulances be in Exeter when they are needed in South Devon? Has the ICB ever seen the roads to Exeter in the summer, especially from rural South Devon?
There is an argument that the ICU needs to save money but where is the financial breakdown? Working in an equal partnership with Exeter and using the existing excellent facilities at Torbay should be cost effective.
How do we fight for our hospital? There is a very active “Heart Campaign” run by Susie Colley, a retired nurse. They have an excellent Facebook group and are now trying to raise money to make a legal challenge to the ICB.
Torbay and the Royal Devon and Exeter Hospitals can work together in an equal partnership but with a larger and older population and a first-class hospital on our doorstep we must fight any attempt to downgrade Torbay.