Devon MP and council in row over claims of 'lies' on housing scrutiny

Resident Thomas Shillitoe dons a waste paper basket on his head - echoing Count Binface - as part of his opposition to a possible major Exmouth housing siteplaceholder image
Resident Thomas Shillitoe dons a waste paper basket on his head - echoing Count Binface - as part of his opposition to a possible major Exmouth housing site | Bradley Gerrard

David Reed, the Conservative member for Exmouth & Exeter East, has accused East Devon District Council of 'lies' over its handling of scrutiny of the Exmo_20 housing site, citing concerns about the site's sustainability and environmental impact.

A war of political words has ramped up between a Devon MP and a district council over claims of “lies” from the authority over its handling of scrutiny of a controversial planning process.

David Reed, the Conservative member for Exmouth & Exeter East, has hit out at East Devon District Council as tensions rise amid ongoing debate about whether a parcel of land on the outskirts of Exmouth should be allocated for housing.

Residents have become increasingly vocal against the so-called Exmo_20 site, as it is named in East Devon’s draft local plan.

Their opposition to it centres on various claims that the prospective 700-home site at St John’s isn’t needed for the council to hit its housing targets, that it is in an unsustainable location, and that its proximity to the internationally recognised Pebblebed Heaths should rule it out under environmental grounds.

David Reed MPplaceholder image
David Reed MP | Submitted

But East Devon believes the site is needed so it can hit its housing target set by the government, says Exmo_20 is deemed suitable because a new access road will be constructed to it, and that it would ensure any assessed harms to plants or animals from the potential development would be mitigated.

Furthermore, allocation in the local plan doesn’t guarantee planning consent, as developers would need to submit applications for approval by the council.

“The debate around Exmo_20 has exposed a far more insidious side to EDDC and its leadership,” Mr Reed said.

“I have seen lies, obfuscation and attempts to shut down people who ask difficult questions.”

Asked if the council had “lied, obfuscated or attempted to shut down difficult questions”, a spokesperson said: “No.

“The council is committed to transparent and lawful decision-making and welcomes public scrutiny and debate as part of its planning processes, particularly in relation to significant issues, such as the allocation of development sites in the emerging local plan.”

In his statement, Mr Reed refers to campaigner Thomas Shillitoe, who initially had part of his comments at one meeting redacted from recorded footage.

Mr Reed said when he queried East Devon about this, the council told him some of the comments had “questioned the professional competence and integrity of a senior council officer”, and that it was “not acceptable to verbally attack individual officers or members of the council in a public setting”.

“That is a serious description, and the bar for calling something a ‘verbal attack’ should be a high one,” Mr Reed said.

“Local people must be able to question the council’s processes, challenge the evidence being relied upon and scrutinise the conclusions being presented to elected members.

“Robust scrutiny should not automatically be characterised as a personal attack.

“There were also problems with the recording of the meeting. Sections were redacted and, after concerns were raised, a senior officer upheld a complaint about one of those redactions.

“The council also acknowledged that the original footage had been edited, meaning the deleted section could not be restored.”

The spokesperson for East Devon District Council acknowledged part or March’s strategic planning committee recording was edited following concerns about comments that were considered to be unsubstantiated allegations about a senior officer.

“While we recognise and support the right of individuals to ask questions, express their views and challenge council decisions and processes, we also have a duty of care towards our staff and a responsibility to ensure that we do not publish anything that is defamatory,” the spokesperson said.

“Everyone attending council meetings is expected to treat others with courtesy and respect. Disruptive, abusive, threatening or discriminatory behaviour will not be tolerated.

“In the process of redacting the comments, a longer section of Mr Shillitoe’s statement was removed than should have been. The related part of the recording could not be retrieved and so the minutes of the meeting were amended to include a summary of these comments to ensure that they were appropriately recorded.

“The council apologised to Mr Shillitoe for redacting more of his statement than was necessary.”

Mr Reed claimed he had received “similar treatment” when asking legitimate questions about Exmo_20 and the infrastructure that would accompany it.

He complained over a statement made at July’s strategic planning committee by the council’s leader, Councillor Paul Arnott (Liberal Democrat, Coly Valley).

A small section of footage has been redacted, although a document showing the latest complaints data for East Devon suggests the council believes no further action is required, albeit a separate complaint – described as being made by ‘an MP’ – could be challenging that decision or be linked to the same issue.

“When elected representatives are asked difficult but legitimate questions, the response should be facts, evidence and openness – not lies, smears and redactions,” Mr Reed said.

The East Devon spokesperson said the redaction took place while the council “considered that comments made by Cllr Arnott could be misconstrued”.

These comments related to a donation made by housing developer 3West, which has already outlined prospective plans for the Exmo_20 site even though the draft local plan hasn’t been ratified.

The donation was made to the Conservative Association prior to Mr Reed’s election in 2024, and declared by him as per Parliamentary rules once he secured his seat.

“Following a review, in line with the council’s procedures and responsibilities, it was concluded that the redaction should remain in place. The minutes of the meeting remain unchanged,” East Devon’s spokesperson said.

Beyond this, the spokesperson added East Devon believed public debate was “vital for democracy”.

“Difficult questions and opposing views are an important part of the planning process and have been central to discussions around the emerging local plan and Exmo_20,” the spokesperson said.

They added redactions were not made because of “political disagreement or criticism of the council” but “in accordance with established procedures”.

“Where concerns are raised about the content of council meeting recordings, we have a responsibility to balance transparency with our legal and governance obligations, including duties relating to staff welfare and defamation law,” the spokesperson said.

“The council remains committed to openness, accountability and respectful public debate.”

Mr Reed said everyone in the Exmouth & Exeter East “cares deeply” about how the area should be developed.

“There should be constructive, cross-party engagement on something as important as this,” he said.

“I do not want this debate to become one of political point-scoring. I want councillors, MPs, developers and local people to be able to work together constructively and get the best possible outcome for our area.”

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice