Exeter city centre car park to make way for controversial new flat scheme

Revised plans for the Mary Arches car park site in Exeter (Image courtesy: Darling Associates Architects/Exeter City Council)placeholder image
Revised plans for the Mary Arches car park site in Exeter (Image courtesy: Darling Associates Architects/Exeter City Council)

Revised plans to demolish Exeter’s Mary Arches Street multi-storey car park and replace it with nearly 300 co-living apartments have been approved after developers reduced building height and redesigned key elements

Almost 300 ‘co-living’ apartments will be built on the site of an Exeter city centre multi-storey car park after developers went back to the drawing board.

Earlier this year, Exeter City Council’s planning committee decided Eutopia’s plans for the Mary Arches Street car park were not good enough and asked the developer to think again.

Now, the revised plans have been given the go-ahead.

“It is obvious that they were listening to what we had to say,” said Cllr Gemma Rolstone (Lab, Topsham).

Since January, Eutopia has made major changes to one of the two proposed blocks. Internal accommodation has been reorganised, and a link between the two blocks has been redesigned. 

The height of the most contentious part of the building has been reduced to four storeys, and a new entrance has been added on the corner of Bartholomew Street and North Street.

The project to demolish the six-deck multi-storey car park can now begin after the committee voted by a majority to approve it.

The full proposal includes the six-storey Block A, which fronts onto Bartholomew Street and North Street and will provide communal facilities including lounges, a gym and studio, co-working space and laundry.

Block B will now be four storeys tall, with an entrance from Mary Arches Street.

The council wants to remove the car park, saying it is obsolete and too expensive to run, and voted in 2022 to proceed with its closure.

Cllr Tess Read (Green, St David’s) argued that the design still had too much massing and would dominate the skyline, while Cllr Diana Moore (Green, St David’s) said the internal design remained “abysmally poor”.

Keith Lewis, of the Exeter Civic Society, said the organisation would prefer to see family homes on the site rather than a large co-living block.

Cllr Rolstone told the meeting: “I am pleased to see that the developer has taken on board the points we made. It’s a better plan than the one we saw previously.”

However, Cllr James Banyard (Green, St David’s) pointed out that Historic England still considered the blocks “excessively tall and bulky”.

The developers will pay £87,000 towards local GP services, £139,000 for travel improvements, £146,436 for car club vehicle provision, and hundreds of pounds per bedspace towards local parks and playing fields.

After the meeting, Cllr Moore said the design changes were not enough.

She said: “Mary Arches car park will change from a big, bland, badly designed, beige block to a big, bland, badly designed, beige block for 297 people.”

Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice