Heartbreak for Torquay United after late, dramatic defeat in Promotion Final

Heartbreak for Torquay United. Pic from PPAUKplaceholder image
Heartbreak for Torquay United. Pic from PPAUK

Gutted Gulls just fall short at Hornchurch in painful late loss

Twice they led, through the heroic Deon Moore. Twice they were pegged back. And, finally and agonisingly, Torquay United were beaten in extra time after a nerve-shredding afternoon at Hornchurch.

The Urchins’ 117th minute winner was scored, with more than a slice of luck, by Sam Ling, the son of former Gulls manager Martin Ling.

Moore had fired Jimmy Ball’s men into an early lead, and he also regained the lead with a quality finish for his eighth goal in five games in the second half.

But Hornchurch equalised first with a Dominic Poleon penalty, after Seb Stacey brought down Charlie Pegrum.

And the snatched promotion from United’s grasp through Henry Hearn in the 93rd minute. 

Penalties looked like a certainty until Ling’s hopeful shot crept in three minutes from the end of extra-time.

So, after so many ups and downs, it’s back to the National League South once again for the Gulls.

Both managers named completely unchanged teams, and benches, from their Semi-Final victories, with Munashe Sundire passed fit to play in midfield after suffering bruised ribs in the 4-2 win over Dorking Wanderers.

United played with a swirling breeze behind them in the first half and, after a nervy start by both sides, Moore struck in spectacular style.

He muscled Giles Phillips aside on a through-ball by left-back Jay Foulston and, as Hornchurch appealed for a foul, Moore unleashed a right-foot volley that beat Arthur Nasta all ends up from 15 yards... 1-0.

The goal seemed to shake Hornchurch for a spell, but they gathered themselves and forced Stacey into two good saves in the 13th minute.

One was a top one, low to his left from Angelo Balanta, and the second a solid one, holding Henry Sandat’s snapshot when a rebound might have been costly.

United worked hard, wingers Young and Morgan tracking back willingly.

And Sundire kept intercepting attacks and getting in timely clearances.

Josh Rees headed just wide in the 27th minute, after the Gulls failed to clear a long throw from the right by Sam Ling.

Hornchurch were on top territorial, but United were coping well, with Jordan Dyer and Sam Dreyer giving nothing away at centre-back.

They nearly broke out to increase the lead in the 40th minute when Lo-Everton let fly from 25 yards and Nasta had to dive to his left to tip the shot behind.

That moment encouraged the Gulls fans, but it also led to the equaliser.

They seemed under no real pressure, with the ball deep in the opposition half, when they were badly caught out by a 44th minute breakaway.

Pegrum’s run from midfield carried him clear on the right, Stacey dashed off his line, took Pegrum’s legs away, and it was an obvious penalty.

Poleon took his time before drilling the spot-kick to the right as Stacey dived the other way... 11-1.

It was a blow to concede when there seemed so little danger on the stroke of half-time, but United started the second half on the front foot.

They couldn’t find any end product to a spell of positive play, which prompted Ball to send on Louis Dennis for Lo-Everton in the 61st minute.

That sparked a spate of other changes, with Callum Dolan also replacing a visibly disappointed Young.

United were still on top, and they started passing the ball with confidence – but still no second breakthrough.

That was until the 78th minute.

Out of nowhere on the left, Dolan produced a moment of magic that Ball must have been hoping for.

Facing his own half, Dolan swivelled and hit a raking diagonal pass which set Moore away on the right.

His first touch was good, his pace kept him clear and he finished with a precision right-foot shot across Nasta and into the bottom left-hand corner... 2-1.

To say that the closing stages were nerve-wracking would be a gross understatement.

Hornchurch, as they had to do, gave it everything.

Time and again Dyer and Dreyer got their heads and boots to the ball as the hosts pumped it forward.

But the pressure grew, United could not keep the ball and in the third minute of stoppage-time the Torquay dam broke.

Substitute Darren McQueen worked some room on the right of the area, chipped a cross into the goalmouth and, after Stacey and teammates almost kept the ball out, Hearn forced it over the line...2-2.

Into extra-time, with Tizzard on for an injured Worthington, with Hayfield into midfield.

United came within an ace of retaking the lead when Dolan’s cross from the right was met by Hayfield’s head and Nasta kept it out with an outrageous point-blank save.

Hayfield also shot just wide from a Dolan corner before Ball played his final card – Reece Evans for Hayfield in half-time of extra time.

Both sides were near exhaustion after yet another draining afternoon. Moore could barely walk, and he wasn’t the only one.

Players were cramping up all over the field.

It was as if they were both bracing themselves for penalties.

But just when you thought that we’d seen it all, it happened.

Ling got his own throw back on the right, cut in, tried a speculate low cross-shot and the ball bobbled across the goalmouth and in off the far post... 2-3.

Hornchurch (4-3-1-2: Nasta; Hare (Greenidge 80), Phillips, Gibbs, Ling; Wright, Pegrum, Poleon (Hearn); Rees (Alexander 80); Balanta (Welch 105), Sandat (McQueen); subs not used – Byrne, Bertram-Cooper.

Booked:

Torquay United (4-1-4-1): Stacey; Hayfield, Dyer, Dreyer, Foulston; Sundire; Young (Dolan 70), Worthington (Tizzard 90+6), Lo-Everton (Dennis 61), Morgan (Jay 85); Moore; subs not used – Hamon, Palmer, Evans.

Booked: Dolan, Dyer.

Attendance: 3,000.

Referee: Matthew Norton (Herts).

Related topics:
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice