Devon and Cornwall Police is far from ‘broken’, PCC insists amid policing reforms

Plans to create the biggest and most significant changes in policing this country has seen in years have begun and it cannot be underestimated how significant they will be for Devon, Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly.  

Last month, the Home Secretary announced the government’s White Paper for reforming what she called the ‘broken’ policing model in England and Wales.

There are plans to create a new national police force and for new regional police forces to be created by merging existing forces. 

While it is clear that improvements can and should be made in certain areas of  policing, I’d like to reassure people reading this that Devon and Cornwall Police is far from ‘broken’.

Through the powers and scrutiny functions of myself and my office to hold the police to account, along with the great leadership of Chief Constable James Vaughan, our force continues to improve its performance. 

In fact, the rules in which the police must function are largely the issue. From the complex bureaucracy of crime recording to producing a file to meet the standards of the Crown Prosecution Service, to court backlogs and the need for officers to create an audit trail for every action to justify everyday interactions, and also misconduct processes which are often onerous and lengthy. 

All of these processes are generally developed by the government — not policing. 

Devon and Cornwall Police is already the largest geographic police force in England with 4,000 sq miles, the largest road network of 13,500 miles and 730 miles of coastline, with policing stretching 12 nautical miles out to sea. It has its own unique challenges including rurality, sparsity, and a significant seasonal influx of tourists. What is so worrying about this is the potential for an erosion of democracy, of accountability and attention. 

Let’s talk numbers. The government grant settlement for Devon and Cornwall has left the force with a budget shortfall of £3.1 million on top of £6.5 million planned efficiencies already to balance the budget for 2026-27. It is one of the lowest government funding settlements for policing nationally, with only four policing areas in England and Wales being left with less spending power — Cleveland, Greater Manchester, Norfolk and South Wales.  

As 43 per cent of the funding for Devon and Cornwall police comes from council taxpayers, a far higher proportion than many other parts of the country, with the rest of the budget coming from central government, it is why I have had to increase the policing element of the police council tax bill by £15 a year for an average Band D property, after gaining approval from the Police and Crime Panel.  

I was left with no choice but to ask taxpayers to pay more to bridge that shortfall from the government settlement. As of 2028, that duty, along with the democratic mandate that I have been given by the public for the last 10 years, is to be abolished.   

Police and crime commissioners are being replaced with either a mayor or a Police and Crime Board consisting of the leaders of our upper tier councils. In the absence of a mayor, in Devon and Cornwall this is likely to mean we have a board.  

This will add a huge complex burden to already overstretched and overworked councillors and officers, especially those busy with local government reorganisation. How can we expect policing and crime to be a priority?  

I fear that the establishment of the National Police Service is a bureaucratic exercise.   

It looks like it is the remaking of the National Police Improvement Agency that Theresa May abolished. 

While it could give greater oversight by bringing several existing separate organisations into one, such as the College of Policing, Police Digital Service and Bluelight Commercial in the first instance, it will be years away from being a National Police Service that delivers operational policing, if indeed that ever happens given that part is planned after the lifetime of the current parliament. 

A government commissioned independent review will report this summer on the number of regional forces and their boundaries. This could see Devon and Cornwall merging with other  forces, but the funding formula won’t be altered until post mergers and restructuring.  

Yet the way the police funding is allocated is the biggest impact the government could have if it reviewed it. The last three times a government tried to do this it failed. I can only surmise it’s because in every iteration the Metropolitan Police loses out and smaller rural forces gain.  

I have long been very vocal about my criticisms of the Police Funding Formula, which has built in over many years unfairness in how police forces are funded.  

At the same time, local government reform will lead to changes to our council boundaries and the government has indicated that a consultation on its preferred option is likely to start next month and also report in the summer, I believe.  

The government has said that “in considering the optimal configuration of police forces… consideration will be given to alignment with other public sector boundaries”.

In other words, both the size of our police force, and the size of the councils, are going to change significantly, possibly at the same time and in a way that tries to achieve similar boundaries. 

I don’t believe the policing reforms will make our streets visibly safer anytime soon — and quite likely never at all — and will have little impact on everyday crimes that affect our lives. It is vital all residents in Devon, Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly are kept updated about the changes in the white paper and it is why an information page is being made available on my office’s website which will have the latest news for people to access over the coming weeks and months.  

In the meantime, I would like to assure residents that both the Office of the Police and Crime Commissioner and Devon and Cornwall Police will continue to listen and act in your best interests and deliver on our priorities of tackling violence, anti-social behaviour, drugs and alcohol and theft.